The Reliability of Self-Reported Menarcheal Timing
Self-reports of grade at first menstrual period for 1,967 fourth-grade through ninth-grade girls were used to categorize girls as early maturers. The categories of early maturer and other (on-time or late maturers) were then examined for stability over a 3-year period using McNemar tests and κ coefficients. Although the results showed significant stability, 15% through 20% of the early maturing girls were eventually reclassified into the other category. This was true for Hispanic, Black, and White girls as well as for 1-, 2-, and 3-year time spans. Implications for measuring menarcheal timing and its effects are discussed.
Smolak, Linda; Krieg, Dana; and al., et, "The Reliability of Self-Reported Menarcheal Timing" (2007). Journal of Early Adolescence 27(3): 386-398. Faculty Publications. Paper 52.
Journal of Early Adolescence